Spider-Man 3 sounds insane, and I can’t wait for a decent DVD to see just how insane — don’t have much choice now, do we… Poor, Poor Village and all. As with many fan geeks, I have a love-hate relationship with Hollywood adaptations of books and comicbooks. In Spider-Man’s case it started with the casting. Let’s illustrate. In the comicbooks, here’s how Peter Parker’s usually drawn by pencillers:

At one point in history, Mike Deodato even modeled Peter after pictures of Jason Priestley. Now here’s who’s casted to play him:
And as if that wasn’t enough, below shows how comic nuts usually identify Harry Osborn:

And this is he on film:

The spider sense tells me of a nefarious switcheroo. How much did Tobey Maguire’s agent bribe Stan Lee? Did James Franco piss someone off in the casting crew, thereby relegating him to the role of what originally was the heroic geek’s geekier-looking friend who sported what looked like funky midget cornrows? It was a good thing the official hairstylist was apparently moved by the beauty of Franco’s luscious locks and desisted to be faithful to canon coiffure on account that this miscasting was sacrilege in the first place.
The creators expounded on wanting to emphasize Peter Parker’s
geekiness when the first installment explored Spider-Man’s origins, and Tobey projected things just right. Okay, Tobey does breathe geek in his sleep, but he’s kind of a boring actor (same tricks, it seems, on almost everything… Pleasantville, Cedar House Rules, Seabiscuit…), and I was just turned off by eventual reports of him kind of holding out for the role allegedly because he wanted to ask for a higher salary after it finally hit him the first movie unexpectedly did well at box office, and he cited a (possibly blown-up) gajillion of injuries from doing the stunts to back up his demand. What a lame play, and of all excuses. Like, if freaking Zhang Ziyi could sign her contract, meekly do all her Yuen Wooping stunts when Zhang Yimou tells her to, and still wind up looking like this on a ladies’ night out? Just shut up, Grampaw.
On getting casted as Mary Jane Watson, the character who eventually married Peter Parker in the comic books, Kirsten Dunst hardly looks like the top fashion model she was supposed to be. Also, Dr. Tom Medicine Woman was dead on when she observed Kirsten is Billy Corgan — with hair and shiny lipgloss — because if you will please:

I am glad, though, that the movie franchise went with the family friend thing MJ Watson was in the book, and the confused childhood and teen years she had… she was a sad, bad girl who found redemption. And though Kirsten was never the traditional classically beautiful ingenue, she more than made up for good looks with an earnestness with her roles, including this one.
The script had Mary Jane Watson figure in the infamous Brooklyn Bridge scene where Gwen Stacy, who was Peter Parker’s original first girlfriend in the comicbook series, plunged to her death after being held hostage by the Green Goblin. Definitely a big TNHIWOP! (that’s not how it went on paper!) factor, however, the creative team pulled the changes off without making things too forced or sometimes bordering on stupid, like what happened to the X-Men adaptations.
So the characters on film developed and surprisingly they went down fine. The script was all right, and the actors did well with the delivery. Many friends thought the CGI web-swinging scenes were a little over the top, but I don’t know. I kind of liked them, especially the ending on 1. We dealt in our shallowly fashion: Peter’s gosh-darn mopey, but he’s a whiney nerd who didn’t deserve the very cool Uncle Ben, so fine. Let him mope. James Franco is SO not right for Harry Osborn (keeps checking the comicbook), but… SO CUTE! MJ Watson — okay… she seems serious about liking Peter despite the fact that he’s a nerdy loser and Harry’s hot. We’re nerds, we like nerds, right? Non-whiney nerds, that is, and well, whatever. She looks cluelessly in love, and true love’s so adorable, never mind it’s Tobey Maguire she’s macking with. Let’s just awww… and get it over with, job well done to those three, and wow, Alex Ross paintings in 2. Acceptance was inevitable, I was moved, I got carried away with their enthusiasm, and everything’s nicely digested by the time Peter and MJ hug with goo-goo eyes, right?
Then I find that in 3, Sam Raimi and Co. had a brilliant idea. Phoom! They recruit GWEN STACY to the motley crew to figure into what was a normal love triangle but is now, like, spatially dimensional. Gwen Stacy, the girl who the Green Goblin originally pushed off the bridge and Spidey just had to save her by webbing, only for her to snap her neck or something, or maybe she was dead by the time Spidey arrived on the scene! I was wrong to think Gwen was, like, cancelled out already given Mary Jane was picked to fall off the bridge, but not snapping her neck or anything (and she does not die and hooks up with Peter despite the presence of James Franco after many twisty turns). And now she pops out of nowhere and she’s the other woman. And she’s played by a narf.
Okay?
I wonder why they picked Gwen Stacy to complicate things between Peter and Mary Jane to keep the interest in their thing from tanking. I mean, why not Felicia Hardy, who moonlights as the Black Cat? The creators of the TV animation series didn’t exactly follow the canon storyline either, but Felicia Hardy worked out just fine in that love triangle mix… she’s a fun girl without the Black Cat persona, she acquires probability-altering powers, and she’s got hidden agenda and skeletons in her closet. What, the contrast will be too much for mopey, aw-shucks film versions of Peter and MJ?
I always thought Gwen Stacy was too one-dimensional, but that’s the product of writers during her stint as official girlfriend. She was replaced by Mary Jane in media incarnations precisely because the Gwen was conceived in the age of comics when women were still stereotypically presented as damsels in distress, and this particular damsel was killed off, anyway, like Namor’s Lady Dorma, preventing character development. In contrast, Sue Storm, Betty Brant, Jean Grey, Trish Tilby, and other super or non-super Marvelettes who lived or were killed off but brought back to life several times out of the 60s were morphed from Donna Reed and Marcia Brady clones to tougher femmes through the years. Gwen Stacy never left the 60s. But then this is Hollywood Marvel. Perhaps there will be a Spider-Man 4 in which Gwen Stacy will mutate into something.
But that’s not all. We have… the Sandman! For convenience, they made him the same thug who killed Uncle Ben! We also have Venom! In the comic book, Spidey got the oozey symbiote when he helped the Fantastic Four, Avengers, X-Men, and other Marvel superheroes fight in the Secret Wars. In space. The ooze followed him back, eventually binding with him until he started crossing to the dark side. He finds out the symbiote was making like Glenn Close in Fatal Attractions. He goes back to the Fantastic Four for help; Mr. Fantastic used a sonic thingamajig to drive the alien away, but the alien escapes and stealthily bonds back with Peter Parker again, so finally Spidey had to drive himself to the church tower so the loud bell clangs separate them again. Film version: the symbiote fell from the sky, having hitchhiked on an asteroid chunk, and yadda-yadda, more or less the same thing happens plus the Gwen Stacy brilliant idea and minus the part with the Fantastic Four.
After Peter’s rejection, the symbiote eventually finds Eddie Brock, a tabloid beat guy and part-time body builder whose familiar physique/countenance is, on average, like so:
Naturally they picked Topher Grace to best bring the bad-assed hardknock to life:

Do you get how these money-makers make money now? Maybe that’s why I’ll never make money the way the money-makers do. Anyway, that picture above was circa Ashton B.D. (before Demi) and Wilmer B.L.L.A.M.M. (before Lindsay Lohan and Mandy Moore). But again, for most of Hollywood Marvel, what’s looks got to do with it? Take Jennifer Garner, she looks nothing like Elektra’s Greek bone structure, exotic eyes and olive skin, and she managed to work the damn sai anyway. Wolverine’s a well-packed 5 feet 3 inches, and Hugh Jackman was taller than James Marsden’s Cyclops, and Cyclops was supposed to be 6 feet 3. Storm should be a majestic 5′ 11″ who’s into wisdom and intone words exchanged in battle like Iman or Grace Jones would, and they give us wispy Halle Berry with a bad wig who chose Marilyn Monroe’s breathey “Happy Birthday, Mr. President” to project that she’s gonna whup goons’ butts. Dr. Doom is Mr. Fantastic’s diabolical and most brilliant arch nemesis — it’s the battle of the nerds here — and how cool was it that he was played by that smarmy demon in Charmed, and got exposed to the same rays the FF went through and wielded electromagnetic powers as a result in the movie? Then he goes down just like that? Where’s the dignity here, people.
Anyway, hope I can check out Spider-Man 3 soon, lots of good reviews from pals (but unfortunately, M, who’s a worse comic geek than anyone I know, opted out of the Friendster loop. His reviews should be interesting. Come back to the F’loop, M, come back!). And what if there will be a Spidey 4? What more can we expect? Wait… I forgot we’re considering insane displacements here. Bryce Dallas Howard said it’s possible Gwen’s a future girlfriend. How about Gwen Stacy becoming the Black Cat!? The original alter-ego, Felicia Hardy, may or may not figure in — maybe it will be Gwen’s alias. Maybe Peter will be more screwed up because of Venom than he thought, go stalker on her and she’ll go under a witness protection program like Mary Jensen. Who cares? It’s the movies. How about Jonathan Lipnicki or Mary-Kate Olsen bagging Carnage, and Paul Giamatti playing the Kingpin? The possibilities boggle the mind.